Safety and Ethical Resources for ICT

Navigating the maze of ethical and safety considerations when working in ICT can be a mine field for teachers and students alike.  Fortunately, there are many helpful resources available to assist.  Below are some of my favorites:




Images of children




Reflective Synopsis


Reflective Synopsis






An overview of the use and value of ICT in the early learning context through the exploration and evaluation of various technology tools.

 The use of ICTs in education is developing at a more expedient rate than the theory to support its use and integration in the education setting, creating disparity in relation to what constitutes elearning and elearning theory (Nichols, 2003). For the purpose of this reflective synopsis, elearning will be defined as a combination of digital content, digital pedagogies and elearning spaces (Education Qld 2008). This includes the use of ICT to enhance learning outcomes including tools such as internet, interactive white boards, data projectors, ipods, cd-roms, blogs, wikis, mobile phones, podcasts and presentation tools such as Glogster and Power Point. I have explored four of these tools, and will reflect upon my learning, understanding and the current literature to support the position that ICTs enhance transform and support student learning.
Image: Education Qld Elearning Framework.

There is a growing amount of research and anecdotal evidence that suggests the use of ICT in the classroom engages 21st Century learners and enhances their learning outcomes (Chickering & Ehrmann 2004). Despite this, there seems to be an undercurrent or resistance form educators to re-evaluate current practice and meet the unique needs of digital narratives (ICT in Education). Today's students' seamlessly integrate and rely on technology for many of the most basic social and recreational needs. As Valdez (2005) states



"It is incomprehensible that anyone today would argue that banks, hospitals, or any industry should use less technology. Most young people cannot understand arguments that schools should limit technology use. For them, use of the Internet, for example, plays a major role in their relationships with their friends, their families, and their schools".



Technology in the education setting has shifted the traditional relationship between educators and students whereby educators were seen as the keepers of knowledge and students the empty vessels (Oliver, 2002). ICT transforms the role of the educator to that of a facilitator of learning, and challenges some of the traditional learning theories. 21st century learning theory's such as connectivism and constructivism change the culture of the classroom and as such the learning experience and outcomes for the students.


It is well established that ICT tools alone not enhance student learning outcomes, as technology in the classroom without effective pedagogy is ineffective. (Newhouse, 2003) However, there is wide spread support that ICT use within the learning environment directly contributes to enhanced learning outcomes for students. Drawing on Valdez's (2005) critique of ICT use in the classroom, he highlights the work of Rubin (Fulton, Feldman, Wasser, Spitzer, Rubin, & McNamara et al., 1996) who argue that other than short term gains such as raising of test scores, technology lends itself to more important outcomes on the learning environment, quoted as:
  • Open the classroom to more communication opportunities.
  • Encourage more teacher-student and student-student discussion.
  • Share the authority as more resources are brought into the classroom.
  • Create opportunities for tasks that are complex and authentic and connected to projects which may be multidisciplinary and long term.
  • Give students more opportunities for multiple ways of discovering, creating, and communicating information in various formats and voices. (Valdez, 2005)
A study conducted by Deakin University (2003) suggest a literature review on the impact of ICT on student learning indicates ICT supports, transforms and enhances learning in the following ways:

  • motivated and stimulated learners;
  • solved some problems of students' 'motivation' for academic work and
  • competence with literacy;
  • encouraged problem solving, analytical and creative thinking;
  • improved students' understandings, assimilation and creation of new
  • knowledge;
  • provided new modes of communication to network locally and globally;
  • provided access to data bases, websites and discussions that were previously
  • unavailable;
  • assisted in the development of independent learning and research skills
  • reduced failure for at risk students.
  • assist in social development and can lead to the new skills necessary for a knowledge society such as digital or network literacy.
  • improve subject learning and vocational training.
  • creates more independent and self motivating learners,
  • encourages the use of multiple teaching methods,
  • encourages team oriented inquiry.

 
In addition ICTs impact curriculum development. An eample of this is the rapidly growing body of declarative knowledge resulting directly in curriculum development that include procedural knowledge to assist in accessing and critically evaluating knowledge sources. Newhouse (2003.p18) also refers to the work of Riel (2008) who states "most educators would perceive the impact of ICT on the curriculum to be positive. With the use of ICT students can use more primary source material and be encouraged to address real problems and develop analytical and interpretive skills ". 


In reflecting on the many ICT tools available I have selected the following four tools for the following learning purposes:



Website: For grade 1 /2 EPL class. Purpose for the site is to enhance parental engagement in the learning by providing an overview of the terms work, provide extracurricular material/activities for students to access, provide examples of students work, reflections of students learning journey.



Podcast: Enhance the class website with students creating their own podcasts including song, story and learning reflections.



Glogster: Multimodal presentation or organisation of information.



Storybird: Engage students in creative writing.



An analysis of these tools including a description, examples, and their application to my ELP context is available via the following links:


 

Website                   Podcast                     Storybird                             Glogster

 

The Committee on Developments in the Science of Learning (2000) suggested five ways to

use ICT to establish and sustain effective learning environments:

1. Real world problems

2. Scaffolding

3. Feedback, reflection and guidance

4. Local and global communities



I will now explore this further through the application of the selected tools: 

Websites and wikis make accessing and exploring environments outside the classroom, community and country easy and convenient for students. Student's knowledge of 'real world problems' can be explored from mainstream media, but websites allow for an alternate view point, including the availability of personal and local stories.


  
An example for my learning context is the topic of animal conservation (Problem based learning) – students can use the web to research current information and statistics on animal conversation throughout the world (Constructivism). This involves the use of both declarative and procedural knowledge. This task would be scaffolded by the educator including suggested search terms, websites, regular guidance and feedback. Students can link in with live webcams such as Cheetah Cam in Africa to experience the animals in their natural environment ,an experience surly not available without such technology. (Situation based learning). 

 

Furthermore, Students can produce a class email to a relevant organisation and request a Skype link up for further discussion (Collaborative learning). Students can follow professionals working on the ground via blogs (Narrative based teaching), listen to podcasts about the issue, and create a Glogster of their learning's for presentation to other school peers or for use to raise money to assist with the cause. Following that, the children can create a story using Storybird about something within the project that inspired, excited or angered them. Without the availability of these tools, some of these tasks would be unachievable. This example also demonstrated how the tools I have explored enhance students learning through the provision of authentic learning experiences and utiliaation of  various learning frameworks such a Blooms Taxonomy.


 

Reflecting on my learning after exploring and experimenting with these tools I have understood the importance of a framework such as TPACK. The task asked that I created something for my ELP context, although I was excited by the possibilities, it was difficult starting at the end – putting the technology/tool ahead of the learning needs. Strong pedagogical framework is essential for any ICT tools to be effective. (Because I own a chisel does not make me a carpenter).



Nichols (2003) states "If eLearning is a means to education, then it can be applied in accordance with varying pedagogies (see Thorpe2002). Weller (2002) lists the following as pedagogies: Constructivism, Resource based learning, Collaborative learning, Problem based learning, Narrative based teaching, Situated learning".



The use of ICTs in the early year's context is not without its barriers. These include student barriers such as technology skill level, confidence, access to technology, individual characteristics such as disabilities/learning styles and familiar support. Educator barriers include technology skill levels, confidence, concerns about cybersafety issues, beliefs and attitude about ICT, time, access to resources, access to technical support and school culture (Bingimlas, 2008).



Exploring further a common barrier for educators and educational institutions is that of the ethical and safety considerations of ICT use. This includes issues such as virus protection, filters to ensure inappropriate materials are not accessed by student either deliberately or inadvertently, cyber bullying, copyright, plagiarism, and unauthorised use of images (such as students photos). Fortunately there is a rapid development of resources to support schools and teachers in managing and educating students and families about these issues. The following link has some suggested resources.


 

 
In conclusion, I approach the use of ICT in the classroom with a renewed respect. Technical skills alone cannot facilitate learning, nor can effective pedagogy stand alone without confidence and technical skill. I have explored four main tools for use in the early years context; Podcasting, Glogster, Websites and Storybird. My learning journey has resulted in an in-depth understanding of the potential of ICT to transform and enhance student learning, and the essential link between ICT and pedagogy.


 

References:



Bingimlas, K.A. (2008) Barriers to the Successful Integration of ICTin teaching and Learning Environments: A Literature Review. Retrieved from http://www.ejmste.com/v5n3/EURASIA_v5n3_Bingimlas.pdf


 

Chickering,W., & Ehrmann, S.C. ( 2004) Implementing the Seven Principles: Technology as Lever Retrieved from http://www.fmtsystems.com/04-news/Impl-7-prin.pdf


 

Deakin University (2003) Effective Use of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) to Enhance Learning for Disadvantaged School Students. Retrieved from http://www.dest.gov.au/NR/rdonlyres/D63F92A3-6931-464F-9970-D599BE3E390E/4520/ICTreport.pdf


 

Education Queensland ( 2008) Elearning for smart classrooms. Retrieved from http://education.qld.gov.au/smartclassrooms/pdf/scbyte-elearning.pdf




Oliver,R. (2002) The role of ICT in higher education for the 21st century: ICT as

a change agent for education. Retreived from citeseerx.ist.psu.edu



Newhouse,P. (2003). The impact if ICT on Teaching and Learning. Retrieved from http://www.det.wa.edu.au/education/cmis/eval/downloads/pd/impactreview.pdf



Nichols (2003) A theory for Elearning Educational Technology & Society, 6(
2), 1-10 Retrieved from http://www.ifets.info/journals/6_2/1.html



Valdez,G. V (2005) Technology: A Catalyst for Teaching and Learning in the Classroom Retrieved from http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/areas/issues/methods/technlgy/te600.htm

Group 4 technology: storybird

I absolutely LOVE the concept of Storybird... its amazing, creative and inspiring.  Storybird is designed to assist with creative writing by providing a range of artwork to inspire the young writers creative expression.  The concept is simple to use with a drag and drop tool, allowing easy use for even the younger grades.   


My initial experience with Storybird was a little frustrating however!  I spent an hour creating the same story concept 3 times!!!!  I initially found the navigation to be very touchy and frustrating - I Lost my stories and then lost my inspiration and creativity - all the things it originally inspired in me!!!!!   I got so wrapped up in my story creation, that twice I accidently hit something off the story board menu with my mouse and ended up on the home page - story gone!!!  That said, I would  love to experiment with this tool with students in creative / expressive writing - I'm actually really looking forward to the day I can use it.  


However, 1 hour later, I could not resist but to go back to the tool, ... I take my daughter with me this time, she is 6 and she is already keen to read the stories and make her own.  I discover my story right where I left it.... so here is my story..


beginnings by shalenob on Storybird


Further analysis of this tool leads me to thinking about more benefits of its use.  The print option is fantastic.  Although online storage is great, a tactile story book is a huge benefit and a means for encouraging the younger students to share their creations with their families and peer.  
The capacity to create a collaborative story as a class is exciting, and again builds group work skills.   The art work is amazing, and a sure inspiration to the even the most unimaginative student, assisting in the area of creative writing.   For those with learning support needs, Storybird also works with Co-Writer word prediction and Dragon Naturally Speaking software.  I love that you can share each others stories, seeing deep into the hearts and minds of your students.  In addition, for myself reading others stories was amazing and inspired me to 'give it a go'. 
Safety and ethical issues have been well thought out by designers; as Mark Ury, (2009) Cofounder of Storybird   states" every Storybird that's shared in the public library is moderated/screened in advance to ensure it's child appropriate and doesn't contain inappropriate language or themes. We also curate and moderate the narrative art supplied by the participating illustrators to ensure that it's appropriate as well. And, the tag and comment engine uses a language scrubber to filter out the vast majority of words used in name-calling. To compliment that, all comments are removable by the thread owner and we do regular sweeps on the daily comment streams to double-check anything the system may have missed."   He also states regarding legal concerns the following measures have been taken -  a) allowing Storybird to allow you to syndicate your content (ie.embeding it on your blog) and b) protecting the existing copyright of illustrators.  (http://www.classroom20.com/forum/topics/storybird-1)  Some drawbacks to the tool include the usual technology issues  (connection speed, access, skill level etc).  I also wonder about the art work being somewhat restrictive to ones imagination - in that if a student cant match the art to their work, are they limited in their story line?  On a forum containing feedback about Storybird as a teaching tool,  the following teacher/student feedback was posted;Ok, six of my kids (gifted ed class grade 4) tried Storybird this afternoon. They really liked it. Here are some of their concerns and comments:
"No easy way to find your book off the frontpage once you have published it."
"No ability to search by author or tag."
"Too hard to find the artwork by using the ' word cloud', most kids want to SEE the art work."
"Only two page layouts, with same size images."
"Can only be one picture on a page"
"Most characters have only one pose--so if you wanted to write a story about only one character he'd always be in the same pose."
"Like the 'creative' outlet."
"Nice to be able to use professional art work--especially if you can't draw"
"Love it!"
"Cute animation makes me want to write a story"

Application:The thing I love about Stoybird, is not only the individual application, whereby a student can express and create, but I'm really excited about the collaborative opportunities Storybird offers.  Some examples can be found here.  When reflecting on how I would use this tool I have lots of ideas that combine collaboration and connectivism learning, to individual application. The artwork is emotionally provoking, and I feel this tool would be excellent to use to explore feelings and empathy.Some more information about Storybird use in the classroom can be found at:http://www.vrml.k12.la.us/curriculum/tech/digital/storybird.htmhttp://kate.murraystate.edu/in_your_classroom/172/http://www.scribd.com/doc/50688300/17/Share-your-Creativity-with-storybird-comhttp://blog.learningtoday.com/blog/bid/26415/Simple-Social-and-Snazzy-Storytelling-with-Storybirdhere
http://www.thedigitalnarrative.com/teachign%20method%20lessons/storybird.htm

Group 3 Technology: Glogster PMI

Group 3 technologies:    

Group 3 technlogies are designed to assist with the presentation of learning or information, and include power point, glogster and prezi.    I have chosen Glogster to analyse as I have some working knowledge of power point, and I found Prezi extremely hard to navigate.  My explorations with power point can be seen here.   I did have a prezi presentation about transport, but when I have accessed it the next time …nothing!

Glogster:
.
Glogster is designed to be an online collage, poster creation that can also upload pictures, text, video and audio. Glogster is free and has the ability for teachers to create class accounts.  Glogster also has an education resource library for teachers providing examples of lesson plans that incorporate glogster examples. Glogster is an online tool and as such can be used individually or utilised to enhance connectivist learning through group work.
There are various benefits to the use of Glogster.  My Glogster creation follows, including a PMI analysis of Glogster.

For the early years context, Glogster is easy to navigate, and as such younger children can work independently around various Glogs, or in small groups.  In addition, with scaffolding and support, the younger children could create their own creative works.

I love the idea of using Glogster to link to the class wiki/website to record and display the children’s work.  ( See this example )

As Glogster combine image, text, audio and video it is useful in accessing all the learning senses and styles.   In the early years environment, in the pre-concrete phase of learning, hands on experimentation and the ‘doing’ is very important ; Glogster can facilitate this given its interactive nature.  In addition, for this developmental age group, repetition, sound and imagery is important and as such glogster provides capacity to meet these specific developmental needs of the students.






Above is a Glogster created to demonstrate the PMI of the tool.

power point experience and analysis

Having used power point in my previous career to conduct training, I thought it would be an easy talk to 'whip up' a power point session with my EPL class in mind...hmmm, 2 hours later, with power point crashing at least 3 times I felt it would NOT be the first multimedia presentation tool I would rush to next time.
Here is my presentation....

Group 2 Technology: Podcasts


Group 2 Technologies:  


Group 2 technologies refers to multimedia: images, video and audio tools.  These tools have been labeled as the ‘new literacy’ of the 21st Centurary ( Lankshear & Knobel, 2003)    New literacy recognises the move away from the focus on traditionally valued notions of literacy that focused primarily on the 3 R’s and incorporates technology tools as a legitimate and effective form of communication .  Susan Marcuss (2005), states “ In surveying these decades of changes in relationship to the discussion of “new literacies,” several important factors stand out:

1. Images and sound are just as important (if not more so) than words and numbers in both their power to capture attention, communicate ideas, and change behavior.

2. The possibilities of using, creating and sharing images, words, sounds (talk/music)
via digital media are now easily imaginable by young people. They’ve adopted the
media and the mindset and they are collectively aware that it is “the future.” The
genie is out of the bottle.

3. It’s a global phenomenon.”




I have undertaken an in depth exploration and analysis of podcasting.   An example of a podcast I have created, including a discussion of its use in the early years context is available below.









As Wes Fryer (2010) describes in Teach Digital a podcast is a file/publication that is stored online, it can be sound, video or other formats but the distinguishing feature of a podcast is that it is a feed that people can subscribe to.  What this means is the file is accessed as it is required by the user through a subscription or file transfer via programmes such as itunes.   A podcast is different from web-based audio in that the purpose of a podcast is for the file to portable – allowing transfer from net to a device such as an ipod or mp3.   There are many available podcasts for education such as these. 


Furthermore, there is easy to use software such as Podmatic  that allows you or your students to develop a podcast.   This is the uniqueness and educational value in this tool; unlike a streaming youtube clip whereby student ‘suck up’ the information, the capacity to develop a podcast as a tool in the classroom setting require both critical and higher order thinking.  Murray (2005) outlines  how the use of sound assists the student to moves through the taxonomy from the taking in of information  such as hearing/learning speech,  to the critical thinking stage such as identifying voices/animals to higher order thinking  skills such as singing/composing or speaking ideas.



The value in this tool includes all the benefits of accessing a range of multiple intelligences (sound, music, words, sight, and pictures) and the capacity to store and access it for easy access in a portable capacity. 




Some other benefits of podcast in the education setting include:     


  •         it allows students to listen to specific material that they missed or did not understand multiple times. (Educational Technology Research and Development)
  • -       you can listen to a podcast whenever and wherever you want to, and you can subscribe to a podcast series so when a new episode is available, it automatically downloads to your computer.  (Podcasting in Education)
  • -       teachers report that students enjoy the time that they spend using the iPods and have made significant learning gains within the talking and listening strand of their English curriculum. (Kervin & Reid, 2006)
  • -       information can be available ‘ on demand’ when students are ready to gear and absorb or create. 
  • -       teachers also report they have learned more about the way their students learn within varying settings and experiences. (Kervin & Reid, 2006)
  • -       Allows of sharing of student learning outside the classroom, facilitating authentic learning opportunities.



Drawbacks to the use of this tool have been noted: these include:   




  • -       “they [the children] focus on the technological side of things a lot rather than the language features of the audio text”. This was further supported by interviews conducted with the students where a consistent theme was the children identifying specific features and capabilities of the iPods rather than how they supported the creation of the radio show.  (Hirtle & White, 2006)  
  •  -       While the use of iPods, podcasts and other personal on demand technologies continue to increase within contemporary society, it appears that many educational settings have not yet adapted to accommodate their use. (Hirtle & White, 2006)  
  • -       Pedagogical frameworks to assist educators in the incorporation of this technology within educational contexts do not yet exist in the literature. ( Kervin & Reid, 2006)
  • -       technological ‘hitches’
  • -       “Student-encountered barriers include: unfamiliarity with podcasts, technical problems in accessing and downloading podcasts, and not seeing the relevance for their learning “(Hew 2008) . 




Applications of podcasting in the early year’s context that I have been thinking about include

  • -       Rhythm and rhyme podcasts to play either in the classroom or load onto a wiki or website for student to access at home, that may assist with alphabet, counting, and phonics. On my first visit to my ELP classroom my Mentor teacher played a song about how to say hello in many languages while the students wrote.  She used this to also let the children know how much time was left to finish their writing, but what I noticed was the children all knew the words, and sang along, knowing hello in at least 10 different languages.   I suspect without the use of this podcast the learning outcomes would not have been so achievable.
  • -        LOTE: both students recording their language skills, and listening to the language.  Using podcasts like a chain letter to other LOTE students.
  • -       Reading records
  • -       Assessment tool for use  of tone control, pronunciation
  • -       Students story telling – either individually or in collaboration
  • -       Music – moving through Blooms taxonomy from recognition to creation – this could include composer, notes, songs, sounds and rhythm
  •    Field trip records
  •  Personal reflections


References:


Doran,H. (nd)  The Helen Doron Early Childhood Education Podcast. Retrieved from http://www.helendoron.com/podcast.php



Educational Technology Research and Development. 57( 3), 333-357, DOI: 10.1007/s11423-008-9108-3

Fryer,W. (2010)  Podcasting: Teach Digital. Retrieved from http://teachdigital.pbworks.com/w/page/19791094/podcasting

Hew, K.F (2008) Use of audio podcast in K-12 and higher education: a review of research topics and methodologies.  DOI 10.1007/s11423-008-9108-

Hirtle,J., &  White,C. (2006)  Pedagogy of Podcasting: mobilizing the tools of contemporary culture for a new generation of learners. Retrieved from http://www.iadis.net/dl/final_uploads/200605F012.pdf

Kervin,L., & Reid,D. (2006). A partnership for iPod pedagogy: Using the technology
of millennial learners across educational contexts Retrieved from http://www.ascilite.org.au/conferences/sydney06/proceeding/pdf_papers/p111.pdf)

Marcuss, S. (2005).  The New Literacies: What Is Basic Education  now?  Retrieved from http://archive.nmc.org/summit/New_Literacies.pdf.

Lankshear, Colin, and Knobel, Michele (2003) New Literacies: changing knowledge and classroom learning. Open University Press, Buckingham, UK.

Lesage,S. (2009) Podcasting as an Educational Tool. Retrieved from 




Podcasting in education, retrieved from http://podcasting-in-education.wikispaces.com/










References

Digital Video

My daughter and I made this Video some time ago, and I it gives me great joy to watch it.  I thought about how it would be wonderful for students to observe and share their learning journey too.  Recording them reading, writing or singing at the start and end of each term would provide -
- record of their physical, emotional and intellectual development ( for student and parent to enjoy)
- additional assessment tool for teacher
- reflective tool for student, teacher and parent

Digital videos can also be viewed by the students, and may include tutorials, instructional seminars, documentaries, field work, or real time link up's via webcams with programmes such as Skype. 

A popular website that includes an almost endless source of digital videos is youtube. 



Group 1 technology : Wikis & Webs & Blogs

Group 1 technology's included wikis, websites and blogs.  For the purpose of this posting, I will explore the use of wikis and websites as teaching tools.


Website: http://wackywebadventures.weebly.com/
I have created a website and am actually excited about its potential real life application.  I have geared this site towards my EPL class next term which is yr 1/2 combined class.  The website serves a two fold purpose.  Firstly it is designed to keep parents informed of their child's learning journey.  It will provide an outline of the terms overview and key learning themes and outcomes.  It also has specific information about how parents can best support their child's learning. As my EPL has not started, it is not complete, but watch this space!

The 2nd purpose of the site is to provide extra curricular activities that match the terms themes.  For example websites, games, uploaded activity sheets etc that reflect the unit.  These could substitute homework at times and generally enhance children deeper learning/understanding.  I know as a parent my children often want to use the computer, and I'm forever looking for different educational sites for them to spend time on in addition to their recreational use - I would love a site that supported/matched their school work.   I shared my idea with my mentor teacher, and she was very excited by this, so no doubt I may complete the site and get to test it out next term!

Functionality of Developing a Website as a Learning Tool:

When exploring the functionality of website development as a learning tool I will apply the SWOT analysis framework.

Strengths:        
image sources from 
http://www.sqleadership.com/

  •  there is much research to support the use of technology assists in engaging learners.
  • 24 hour access, allowing students to access, explore and utilize the website outside of school
  • connects school to home allowing family members to be apart of student learning journey
  •  environmentally friendly manner to store teachers/students work, information ( reduction in paper, folders etc)
  • contributes to broader student/community learning as accessible to broad audience, and as such
  • can provide of external input/feedback from experts in the field and links with similar interest groups for students. 
  • can be less resource intense and may provided greater expression of creativity for teacher - eg: unit on the jungle may contain links to live webcams', Google earth, ( virtual excursions), museums, photographs etc that would not be as accessible with the technology. 
  •  Transparent - allows for easy peer and parent critique/review which may enhance teachers performance. 
  • greater possibility of cultural perspectives in education ( eg world wide web access allows ease of cultural comparison, learning)

pic sourced from
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/ 

Weaknesses:

  • technology failure
  • unpredictability of technology
  • cost - update of software and hardware
  • class discrimination - presupposition that family have the means to buy the equipment and have funds to pay electricity, internet connection
  • internet safety precautions 
  • ethical issues such as plagiarism
  • some children/families believe that there are electron-magnetic fields produced by electric appliances ( e.g lap tops computers) causing serious health issues
Opportunities
  • Increased competition, and availability of educational specific website software
  • Increase in funded technology resources to schools/students
  • Broader development of internet safety policy and resources
  • increased professional development for educators in ICT


Threats:       
In addition to the above mentioned threats, consideration must be given to:

  • Technology reliances increases the power of multi national companies,who own the technology, licenses and phone lines, who are responsible for exploiting workers and increased environmental damage. 
  • Technology is often superseded at a rapid pace and as such reliance on technology contributes to the 'throw away'society resulting in increased environmental damage. 

Another Group 1 technology is a Wiki:

Wiki: http://sharongraham.wikispaces.com/ 
The development of my Wiki was also designed with my EPL class group in mind.  In thinking about the Literacy course, and reflecting on my own childs love of books, I thought a wiki maybe an easy way for parents teachers and students to share there favorite books, reading website and activities. I imagined over the years it would grow to home a very comprehensive list of resources that could also link to the website for additional materials for parents/students.

PMI on Wiki use:

Positives:
  • students can directly contribute to the wiki, resulting in increased engagement and ownership of their learning
  • International - contributions can be from a wide variety of experiences, allowing diversity in culture, gender, class, religion, and geography.
  • 24 hour assess, allowing students to access, explore and utilize the website outside of school 
  • connects school to home allowing family members to be apart of student learning journey
  • easily accessible 'storage file'of resources, student work
  • allows students / teachers to easily share and critique each others work
Minises: 
In addition to the website threats and weaknesses listed above, Wiki may present additional issues such as
  • editing/changing of wiki by students may present issues with loss of information, inappropriate comments/postings
Interesting:
  • need for further development issues of intellectual copyright for educators and students
  • endless creativity of educators/students always amazes me, and I feel privileged to be able to so easily view/access this. 
I was amazed at how easy it was to create both the wiki and the website, and would  feel confident in utilizing these tools in the future.

Conclusion and Reflections weeks 1-3 ( assignment I)




                                                          and Conclusion.....

Over the last 3 weeks I have participated as an active learner and student in a range of scaffolded activities centred on e-learning theory and design.  The following blog entry provides a summary and evaluation of my experience and an overview of the prominent themes and concepts within this learning journey.

One of the early concepts introduced was learning styles and Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences.  Multiple Intelligences theory recognising eight different styles of intelligences that allow for broader recognition of students potential (Armstrong, 2009).  The activities allowed exploration of one’s own learning styles preferences, an important process to undertake as a teacher as teachers tend to teach to their own learning style.  As such, understanding and awareness of your own bias in learning styles allows for a more conscious development of strategies that can attend to the multiple learning styles of students (Reinhold, 2011).   The e-learning design provided for various learning styles as evidenced in the provision of text, video, online tutorials, individual and group work.    

 Another key concept I have explored is learning theory.   Throughout the activities we have been encouraged to recognise and evaluate what have been the dominant learning theories underpinning the activities. Behavioural, cognitivism, constructivsim, Connectivism and multiple intelligences were the main learning theories explored, and were all evident within the activities.  However, it is my assessment that the e-learning design approach for these activities was underpinned largely by connectivism learning theory.  "In connectivism, the starting point for learning occurs when knowledge is actuated through the process of a learner connecting to and feeding information into a learning community.  Siemens (2004) states, “A community is the clustering of similar areas of interest that allows for interaction, sharing, dialoguing, and thinking together.” Kop & Hill (2008).

Many of the activities within the first 3 weeks relied on students working  as a part of a team.  The design provided various means for this to occur such as wiki’s, online tutorials and forums.  The endless forum discussions in relation to the tasks highlighted students ease at utilising the digital world to enhance their learning.   This followed Kearsley & Shneiderman (1999) assessment that   “The fundamental idea underlying engagement theory is that students must be meaningfully engaged in learning activities through interaction with others and worthwhile tasks “.  Without the goal orientated and collaboratively focused activities, it is very likely  my engagement and participation with the material would have been reduced.    

 Constructionist, cognitivist and behavioural learning theory influences were also apparent as discussed in learning theories blog.   Despite the scaffolding provided, it was clear that the design of the activities challenged students to work in the higher range of Blooms Taxonomy.  For the digital immigrants, it is my observation that this caused a level of stress for a number of students; however I suspect the learning outcomes resulting from this challenge were significant.   Reflecting on my own experience of this design, I found the online environment difficult to adjust to, and often felt isolated from my peers despite the many online opportunities for connection.  In addition, the technological issues such as wiki and blog addresses continually being removed added to my frustration.   This feeling was supported by broader research in relation e-learning experience stating  “ Current research in adult education shows that the levels of confidence and learner autonomy, in addition to discipline, are of crucial importance to the level of engagement by the learner in a personalized learning environment, as lack of these in the majority of participants hampered their learning online.  Nearly all students preferred the help and support of the local or online tutor to guide them through resources and activities, to validate information, and to critically engage them in the course content (Kop, 2008), which would indicate the need for a localized tutor presence” Kop & Hill (2008).  

Reflecting on other student’s participation it was apparent that patterns replicated any other learning environment that I had attended, in that there were some students that had high participation, and core group with mid-ranged participation, and some those that contributed in a limited manner.  It was also evident that contribution increase or was often centred on assessment, highlighting students motivation to do well.  Reflecting on how this may influence my own e-learning design I would be interested in exploring further how participation/contribution reflects learning outcomes; i.e is there any difference in the learning outcomes of those students who participated in forums etc to those that were the ‘quiet participants?’.

Another concept that was introduced related to e-learning design and Blooms Taxonomy.  It was evident that the design of the activities demonstrated an alignment with Bloom’s Taxonomy, moving through knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation.   

“ Each category entails more intricate thinking than the one preceding it and integrates the previous levels of thought to advance to higher levels” ( Journal of Education for Business , 2009).  This design has relied on scaffolding to ensure as students progress through the activities they are building on prior knowledge and skills, with the early weeks introducing new concepts skills at a basic level, with the intention to build on knowledge and application each week.  Reflecting on the last 3 weeks in my own learning journey it was apparent I was moving through this taxonomy, as evidence in initially not knowing what a wiki was, to contributing to a wiki and evaluating its impact on my learning.


 University of Tasmania (nd) state Effective scaffolding makes two major contributions
·         makes it easier for the learner to undertake a task successfully and thus expands the possible learning activities and experiences
·         increases the rate at which learning may be achieved, and extends what is possible for a learner to perform.

In the online environments such as wikis and blogs, scaffolding occurred with the aid of tools such as  PMI and De Bono’s Hats.  These tools assisted students to clarify and organise their thoughts and analysis of the text/issue enabling higher order thinking .  Using the blogs and wikis as a space to house these higher order thoughts provided a comprehensive and holistic representation of the issue which further enabled learning.   “ Encouraging a learner to follow through a defined pattern of thinking steps represents a reflective process that may also be explained as a creativity heuristic. The thinking steps underpinning a reflective tool can be designed as content-free ' empty' templates. The learner can use these generic reflective tools as a self-coaching device, developing an ability to focus thoughts and ideas and turn them into useful concepts and knowledge” (Coombs, 1999).

In reflecting on the implications for my own learning design, the risk would be to focus on the knowing; the ascertainment of knowledge, rather than the skill to critic and evaluate knowledge.  Ensuring  a focus on teaching  ‘thinking steps’ reduces these risks, and provides for lifelong critical analysis skills and as such must be a part of any learning design. . 

Reflecting on my overall experience of ICTs as a learning tool, I am able to recognise the significant potential for enhancing learning.  “ IT is a particularly powerful teaching tool because it opens up access to a rich variety of resources, it enables flexible thinking to flourish, and because of its infinite patience IT can operate as an inexhaustible learning coach”  Coombs (1999) .  I have observed more closely my own children’s engagement with technology in their learning, and started to think more critically about how concepts of TPACK are crucial in any curriculum.  

I have broader structural concerns about equal distribution of resources and the impact of issues such as class and culture on learning outcomes specific to ICT.   As the divide between rich and poor expands, and we become more aware of the impact of psychosocial issues on students, such as mental health, parental drug dependence and domestic violence, any push for ICTs at the institutional level must take into account these inequities, and not further disadvantage at risk children.  

Although early days, I can recognise my own learning experience in this digital world has been valuable and I feel I have challenged and engaged in the material and can recognise a significant leaning growth.

References:
Armstrong, T (2009).   Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom 3rd ed. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Retrieved from  http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/109007.aspx
Coombs, S J., Smith, I. (1999). Integration of critical and creative thinking skills into Singapore's IT postgraduate teacher education programme.  Change .2(2),  80-92. Retrieved from http://ses.library.usyd.edu.au/bitstream/2123/4356/1/Vol2No2Article6.pdf

Kop, R., &  Hill, A. (2008)  Connectivism: Learning theory of the future or vestige of the past? The International Review of Learning in Open and Distance Learning. 9(3).  Retrieved from http://irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/523/1103.

Halawi, L., McCarthy, R., Pires, S.,(2009).  An Evaluation of E-Learning on the Basis of Bloom's Taxonomy: An Exploratory Study. Journal of Education for Business  84 (6), p374-380.

Reinhold ,R. ( 2011).  Career Choice and Career Development: Using the MBTI ® and Personality Type. Retrieved from  http://www.personalitypathways.com/article/career-plan2.html. 


University of Tasmania. (nd)  Children, on-line learning and authentic teaching skills
in primary education. Retrieved from
http://www.educ.utas.edu.au/users/ilwebb/Research/scaffolding.htm