Digital Video

My daughter and I made this Video some time ago, and I it gives me great joy to watch it.  I thought about how it would be wonderful for students to observe and share their learning journey too.  Recording them reading, writing or singing at the start and end of each term would provide -
- record of their physical, emotional and intellectual development ( for student and parent to enjoy)
- additional assessment tool for teacher
- reflective tool for student, teacher and parent

Digital videos can also be viewed by the students, and may include tutorials, instructional seminars, documentaries, field work, or real time link up's via webcams with programmes such as Skype. 

A popular website that includes an almost endless source of digital videos is youtube. 



Group 1 technology : Wikis & Webs & Blogs

Group 1 technology's included wikis, websites and blogs.  For the purpose of this posting, I will explore the use of wikis and websites as teaching tools.


Website: http://wackywebadventures.weebly.com/
I have created a website and am actually excited about its potential real life application.  I have geared this site towards my EPL class next term which is yr 1/2 combined class.  The website serves a two fold purpose.  Firstly it is designed to keep parents informed of their child's learning journey.  It will provide an outline of the terms overview and key learning themes and outcomes.  It also has specific information about how parents can best support their child's learning. As my EPL has not started, it is not complete, but watch this space!

The 2nd purpose of the site is to provide extra curricular activities that match the terms themes.  For example websites, games, uploaded activity sheets etc that reflect the unit.  These could substitute homework at times and generally enhance children deeper learning/understanding.  I know as a parent my children often want to use the computer, and I'm forever looking for different educational sites for them to spend time on in addition to their recreational use - I would love a site that supported/matched their school work.   I shared my idea with my mentor teacher, and she was very excited by this, so no doubt I may complete the site and get to test it out next term!

Functionality of Developing a Website as a Learning Tool:

When exploring the functionality of website development as a learning tool I will apply the SWOT analysis framework.

Strengths:        
image sources from 
http://www.sqleadership.com/

  •  there is much research to support the use of technology assists in engaging learners.
  • 24 hour access, allowing students to access, explore and utilize the website outside of school
  • connects school to home allowing family members to be apart of student learning journey
  •  environmentally friendly manner to store teachers/students work, information ( reduction in paper, folders etc)
  • contributes to broader student/community learning as accessible to broad audience, and as such
  • can provide of external input/feedback from experts in the field and links with similar interest groups for students. 
  • can be less resource intense and may provided greater expression of creativity for teacher - eg: unit on the jungle may contain links to live webcams', Google earth, ( virtual excursions), museums, photographs etc that would not be as accessible with the technology. 
  •  Transparent - allows for easy peer and parent critique/review which may enhance teachers performance. 
  • greater possibility of cultural perspectives in education ( eg world wide web access allows ease of cultural comparison, learning)

pic sourced from
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/ 

Weaknesses:

  • technology failure
  • unpredictability of technology
  • cost - update of software and hardware
  • class discrimination - presupposition that family have the means to buy the equipment and have funds to pay electricity, internet connection
  • internet safety precautions 
  • ethical issues such as plagiarism
  • some children/families believe that there are electron-magnetic fields produced by electric appliances ( e.g lap tops computers) causing serious health issues
Opportunities
  • Increased competition, and availability of educational specific website software
  • Increase in funded technology resources to schools/students
  • Broader development of internet safety policy and resources
  • increased professional development for educators in ICT


Threats:       
In addition to the above mentioned threats, consideration must be given to:

  • Technology reliances increases the power of multi national companies,who own the technology, licenses and phone lines, who are responsible for exploiting workers and increased environmental damage. 
  • Technology is often superseded at a rapid pace and as such reliance on technology contributes to the 'throw away'society resulting in increased environmental damage. 

Another Group 1 technology is a Wiki:

Wiki: http://sharongraham.wikispaces.com/ 
The development of my Wiki was also designed with my EPL class group in mind.  In thinking about the Literacy course, and reflecting on my own childs love of books, I thought a wiki maybe an easy way for parents teachers and students to share there favorite books, reading website and activities. I imagined over the years it would grow to home a very comprehensive list of resources that could also link to the website for additional materials for parents/students.

PMI on Wiki use:

Positives:
  • students can directly contribute to the wiki, resulting in increased engagement and ownership of their learning
  • International - contributions can be from a wide variety of experiences, allowing diversity in culture, gender, class, religion, and geography.
  • 24 hour assess, allowing students to access, explore and utilize the website outside of school 
  • connects school to home allowing family members to be apart of student learning journey
  • easily accessible 'storage file'of resources, student work
  • allows students / teachers to easily share and critique each others work
Minises: 
In addition to the website threats and weaknesses listed above, Wiki may present additional issues such as
  • editing/changing of wiki by students may present issues with loss of information, inappropriate comments/postings
Interesting:
  • need for further development issues of intellectual copyright for educators and students
  • endless creativity of educators/students always amazes me, and I feel privileged to be able to so easily view/access this. 
I was amazed at how easy it was to create both the wiki and the website, and would  feel confident in utilizing these tools in the future.

Conclusion and Reflections weeks 1-3 ( assignment I)




                                                          and Conclusion.....

Over the last 3 weeks I have participated as an active learner and student in a range of scaffolded activities centred on e-learning theory and design.  The following blog entry provides a summary and evaluation of my experience and an overview of the prominent themes and concepts within this learning journey.

One of the early concepts introduced was learning styles and Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences.  Multiple Intelligences theory recognising eight different styles of intelligences that allow for broader recognition of students potential (Armstrong, 2009).  The activities allowed exploration of one’s own learning styles preferences, an important process to undertake as a teacher as teachers tend to teach to their own learning style.  As such, understanding and awareness of your own bias in learning styles allows for a more conscious development of strategies that can attend to the multiple learning styles of students (Reinhold, 2011).   The e-learning design provided for various learning styles as evidenced in the provision of text, video, online tutorials, individual and group work.    

 Another key concept I have explored is learning theory.   Throughout the activities we have been encouraged to recognise and evaluate what have been the dominant learning theories underpinning the activities. Behavioural, cognitivism, constructivsim, Connectivism and multiple intelligences were the main learning theories explored, and were all evident within the activities.  However, it is my assessment that the e-learning design approach for these activities was underpinned largely by connectivism learning theory.  "In connectivism, the starting point for learning occurs when knowledge is actuated through the process of a learner connecting to and feeding information into a learning community.  Siemens (2004) states, “A community is the clustering of similar areas of interest that allows for interaction, sharing, dialoguing, and thinking together.” Kop & Hill (2008).

Many of the activities within the first 3 weeks relied on students working  as a part of a team.  The design provided various means for this to occur such as wiki’s, online tutorials and forums.  The endless forum discussions in relation to the tasks highlighted students ease at utilising the digital world to enhance their learning.   This followed Kearsley & Shneiderman (1999) assessment that   “The fundamental idea underlying engagement theory is that students must be meaningfully engaged in learning activities through interaction with others and worthwhile tasks “.  Without the goal orientated and collaboratively focused activities, it is very likely  my engagement and participation with the material would have been reduced.    

 Constructionist, cognitivist and behavioural learning theory influences were also apparent as discussed in learning theories blog.   Despite the scaffolding provided, it was clear that the design of the activities challenged students to work in the higher range of Blooms Taxonomy.  For the digital immigrants, it is my observation that this caused a level of stress for a number of students; however I suspect the learning outcomes resulting from this challenge were significant.   Reflecting on my own experience of this design, I found the online environment difficult to adjust to, and often felt isolated from my peers despite the many online opportunities for connection.  In addition, the technological issues such as wiki and blog addresses continually being removed added to my frustration.   This feeling was supported by broader research in relation e-learning experience stating  “ Current research in adult education shows that the levels of confidence and learner autonomy, in addition to discipline, are of crucial importance to the level of engagement by the learner in a personalized learning environment, as lack of these in the majority of participants hampered their learning online.  Nearly all students preferred the help and support of the local or online tutor to guide them through resources and activities, to validate information, and to critically engage them in the course content (Kop, 2008), which would indicate the need for a localized tutor presence” Kop & Hill (2008).  

Reflecting on other student’s participation it was apparent that patterns replicated any other learning environment that I had attended, in that there were some students that had high participation, and core group with mid-ranged participation, and some those that contributed in a limited manner.  It was also evident that contribution increase or was often centred on assessment, highlighting students motivation to do well.  Reflecting on how this may influence my own e-learning design I would be interested in exploring further how participation/contribution reflects learning outcomes; i.e is there any difference in the learning outcomes of those students who participated in forums etc to those that were the ‘quiet participants?’.

Another concept that was introduced related to e-learning design and Blooms Taxonomy.  It was evident that the design of the activities demonstrated an alignment with Bloom’s Taxonomy, moving through knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation.   

“ Each category entails more intricate thinking than the one preceding it and integrates the previous levels of thought to advance to higher levels” ( Journal of Education for Business , 2009).  This design has relied on scaffolding to ensure as students progress through the activities they are building on prior knowledge and skills, with the early weeks introducing new concepts skills at a basic level, with the intention to build on knowledge and application each week.  Reflecting on the last 3 weeks in my own learning journey it was apparent I was moving through this taxonomy, as evidence in initially not knowing what a wiki was, to contributing to a wiki and evaluating its impact on my learning.


 University of Tasmania (nd) state Effective scaffolding makes two major contributions
·         makes it easier for the learner to undertake a task successfully and thus expands the possible learning activities and experiences
·         increases the rate at which learning may be achieved, and extends what is possible for a learner to perform.

In the online environments such as wikis and blogs, scaffolding occurred with the aid of tools such as  PMI and De Bono’s Hats.  These tools assisted students to clarify and organise their thoughts and analysis of the text/issue enabling higher order thinking .  Using the blogs and wikis as a space to house these higher order thoughts provided a comprehensive and holistic representation of the issue which further enabled learning.   “ Encouraging a learner to follow through a defined pattern of thinking steps represents a reflective process that may also be explained as a creativity heuristic. The thinking steps underpinning a reflective tool can be designed as content-free ' empty' templates. The learner can use these generic reflective tools as a self-coaching device, developing an ability to focus thoughts and ideas and turn them into useful concepts and knowledge” (Coombs, 1999).

In reflecting on the implications for my own learning design, the risk would be to focus on the knowing; the ascertainment of knowledge, rather than the skill to critic and evaluate knowledge.  Ensuring  a focus on teaching  ‘thinking steps’ reduces these risks, and provides for lifelong critical analysis skills and as such must be a part of any learning design. . 

Reflecting on my overall experience of ICTs as a learning tool, I am able to recognise the significant potential for enhancing learning.  “ IT is a particularly powerful teaching tool because it opens up access to a rich variety of resources, it enables flexible thinking to flourish, and because of its infinite patience IT can operate as an inexhaustible learning coach”  Coombs (1999) .  I have observed more closely my own children’s engagement with technology in their learning, and started to think more critically about how concepts of TPACK are crucial in any curriculum.  

I have broader structural concerns about equal distribution of resources and the impact of issues such as class and culture on learning outcomes specific to ICT.   As the divide between rich and poor expands, and we become more aware of the impact of psychosocial issues on students, such as mental health, parental drug dependence and domestic violence, any push for ICTs at the institutional level must take into account these inequities, and not further disadvantage at risk children.  

Although early days, I can recognise my own learning experience in this digital world has been valuable and I feel I have challenged and engaged in the material and can recognise a significant leaning growth.

References:
Armstrong, T (2009).   Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom 3rd ed. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Retrieved from  http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/109007.aspx
Coombs, S J., Smith, I. (1999). Integration of critical and creative thinking skills into Singapore's IT postgraduate teacher education programme.  Change .2(2),  80-92. Retrieved from http://ses.library.usyd.edu.au/bitstream/2123/4356/1/Vol2No2Article6.pdf

Kop, R., &  Hill, A. (2008)  Connectivism: Learning theory of the future or vestige of the past? The International Review of Learning in Open and Distance Learning. 9(3).  Retrieved from http://irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/523/1103.

Halawi, L., McCarthy, R., Pires, S.,(2009).  An Evaluation of E-Learning on the Basis of Bloom's Taxonomy: An Exploratory Study. Journal of Education for Business  84 (6), p374-380.

Reinhold ,R. ( 2011).  Career Choice and Career Development: Using the MBTI ® and Personality Type. Retrieved from  http://www.personalitypathways.com/article/career-plan2.html. 


University of Tasmania. (nd)  Children, on-line learning and authentic teaching skills
in primary education. Retrieved from
http://www.educ.utas.edu.au/users/ilwebb/Research/scaffolding.htm

Elearning Design Framework

Below is an e learning design framework I have developed that has attempted to blend the concepts within Blooms Taxonomy and Learning Engagement theory, while considering various learning styles, and curricular outcomes.  The framework is applied in the form of a checklist to work through during, and specifically after, the development of an e learning activity.   It is envisaged that should there be areas within the checklist that have little or no ticks, the need to adjust or scaffold the learning activity accordingly would be apparent. 


E learning Design Framework Checklist.....


What is the Learning Aim??


How does it link to the Curriculum?




What are the....
1.    Cognitive knowledge aims/ areas of thinking?
ü  Remembering ....  is there
¨  Recognising
¨  Listing
¨  Describing
¨  Identifying
¨  Retrieving
¨  Naming
¨  Locating
¨  Finding

ü  Understanding......is there
¨  Interpreting
¨  Summarising
¨  Inferring
¨  Paraphrasing,
¨  Classifying
¨  Comparing
¨  Explaining
¨  Exemplifying

ü  Applying.... is there
¨  Implementing
¨  carrying out
¨  using
¨  executing

ü  Analysing.... is there
¨  Comparing
¨  Organising
¨  Deconstructing
¨  Attributing
¨  Outlining
¨  Finding
¨  Structuring
¨  integrating

ü  Evaluating.....is there
¨  Checking
¨  Hypothesising
¨  Critiquing
¨  Experimenting
¨  Judging
¨  Testing
¨  Detecting
¨  Monitoring

ü  Creating.... is there
¨  Designing
¨  Constructing
¨  Planning
¨  Producing
¨  Inventing
¨  devising, making


2.    Social/emotional skills aims? ... is there
¨  Collaboration
¨  Team work
¨  Group work
¨  Perspective building
¨  Resilience building
¨  Self ethnicity
¨  Cooperation
¨  Responsibility
¨  Negotiation
¨  Friendship
¨  Planning
¨  Time management

How is It Authentic?
¨  Is it project based
¨  Does it have outside application?
¨  Have the students had input into the topic/problem definition
¨  Is there opportunity for creative expression/interpretation
¨  Is there a defined specific context for the learning

How is It Collaborative?
¨  Partner work
¨  Group work
¨  Forums
¨  Peer assessment
¨  Formal learning groups
¨  Informal learning groups
¨  Is there elements of interdependence


Does it Allow for various Learning Styles/Multiple Intelligences
¨  Visual
¨  Auditory
¨  Kinaesthetic
¨  Visual Intelligence
¨  Logical intelligence
¨  Verbal Intelligence
¨  Kinaesthetic Intelligence
¨  Musical Intelligence
¨  Interpersonal Intelligence
¨  Intrapersonal Intelligence


What ICT Resources will be utilised/best match to the learning outcome/task?
¨  Email
¨  Blog
¨  Wikis
¨  Mobile phone
¨  Forum
¨  Internet research
¨  Online quiz
¨  Online gaming
¨  Video
¨  Power point

Have the ethical/safety issues been considered?
¨  Parental permission/advice
¨  Personal online safety information provided
¨  Students have equal access to resources
¨  Students have the technological skills to complete task
¨  Students are aware how to access my help/assistance



Mobile Phone Wiki….. Hats and Phones



Initially after viewing the article and watching the video, I wondered what could possibly come out of this simple concept of mobile phone use in schools...and then I read all the responses on the wiki...wow! I was amazed at how such a small exercise generated such a wide variety of responses and discussion. Hats off to de Bono ( no pun intended).    The structure of the wiki, following the de Bono's Six Thinking Hats concept allows for analysis and conciseness in the posts, and ease for the reader to work through and synthesizes the material. As Six Thinking Hats® website states "The difference between brilliant and mediocre teams isn't so much in their collective mental capacity, but in how well they can tap into their collective wisdom and how well they function together". There is no way that on my own, or even in a small working group could all the perspectives and evaluations of the topic 'mobile phone in the classroom' have been explored as they were in this activity. This suggests to me that this concept can enhance group work outcomes within the classroom, assuming all participants actually participate.

Reflecting on the process of the experience, I have to say it took 3 attempts before my contribution loaded; a very quick lesson learnt in writing my evaluations/thoughts in MS Word and not directly into a wiki. At that point I was thinking it was all too difficult and faced the common pit fall of ICT – you know when it IT part fails. Fortunately, persistence prevailed and my contributions were loaded.  Reflecting on other's postings, I did find that I wanted to pursue/question some contributors statements/thinking, however there was little avenue to do this, so in some ways I felt the activity lacked an 'ending' - a space to discuss and debate - the essential part in consolidating learning, as highlighted in social constructionist theroy.  Perhaps if I used this exercise I would add an extra step either face to face or in a same time space for the groups to feedback a shared synthesis and discuss the findings.   



Despite this hick-up, I can see great value in this tool as a learning activity. Posting something for my peers to read also provided additional motivation for me to be clear and conscious and mindful of my audience - perhaps more than I may have been if my audience was only my teacher?  I think for young people, peer evaluation and feedback can be more highly weighted than that of teachers, and as such, a strategy like this may provide additional motivation for students to achieve, express or create. This notion is supported by recent research by the National Taiwan University of Science and Technology (2010) that states "the students' responses also showed that they were highly confident and strongly intrinsically motivated when participating in an online peer assessment learning environment".


A blend of cognitivism, constructivism and connectivism learning theory, this activity appealed to me as it allowed the time I needed to process the material, and form my own higher order thoughts about both the evaluation of the concept and its application in the classroom. Again, a positive tool that can meet various learning styles within the classroom setting. The activity was cognitivist in the way is used Vygotsky's concept of scaffolding. Again like many of the Elearning designs in this course, the scaffolding has assisted in reducing my anxiety and providing clear steps and pre-determined outcomes in my learning journey. There were elements of constructivism also in the evaluation and analysis of the material – de Bonos hat activity was very constructionist based as it relied on each person providing their own individual interpretation of the material. The connectivist characteristic were demonstrated in the sharing and reflecting on each other's evaluations within the wiki, even though the contact was no direct or through 'same time discussion' there was for a me a shared connection to my peers in relation to their analysis and perceptions of the material. So in summary, overall my the learning outcomes of this activity outweighed the technological issues I experienced, and I would feel confident enough to have this style of scaffolded Elearning tool in my teacher tool box.