Initially after viewing the article and watching the video, I wondered what could possibly come out of this simple concept of mobile phone use in schools...and then I read all the responses on the wiki...wow! I was amazed at how such a small exercise generated such a wide variety of responses and discussion. Hats off to de Bono ( no pun intended). The structure of the wiki, following the de Bono's Six Thinking Hats concept allows for analysis and conciseness in the posts, and ease for the reader to work through and synthesizes the material. As Six Thinking Hats® website states "The difference between brilliant and mediocre teams isn't so much in their collective mental capacity, but in how well they can tap into their collective wisdom and how well they function together". There is no way that on my own, or even in a small working group could all the perspectives and evaluations of the topic 'mobile phone in the classroom' have been explored as they were in this activity. This suggests to me that this concept can enhance group work outcomes within the classroom, assuming all participants actually participate.
Reflecting on the process of the experience, I have to say it took 3 attempts before my contribution loaded; a very quick lesson learnt in writing my evaluations/thoughts in MS Word and not directly into a wiki. At that point I was thinking it was all too difficult and faced the common pit fall of ICT – you know when it IT part fails. Fortunately, persistence prevailed and my contributions were loaded. Reflecting on other's postings, I did find that I wanted to pursue/question some contributors statements/thinking, however there was little avenue to do this, so in some ways I felt the activity lacked an 'ending' - a space to discuss and debate - the essential part in consolidating learning, as highlighted in social constructionist theroy. Perhaps if I used this exercise I would add an extra step either face to face or in a same time space for the groups to feedback a shared synthesis and discuss the findings.
A blend of cognitivism, constructivism and connectivism learning theory, this activity appealed to me as it allowed the time I needed to process the material, and form my own higher order thoughts about both the evaluation of the concept and its application in the classroom. Again, a positive tool that can meet various learning styles within the classroom setting. The activity was cognitivist in the way is used Vygotsky's concept of scaffolding. Again like many of the Elearning designs in this course, the scaffolding has assisted in reducing my anxiety and providing clear steps and pre-determined outcomes in my learning journey. There were elements of constructivism also in the evaluation and analysis of the material – de Bonos hat activity was very constructionist based as it relied on each person providing their own individual interpretation of the material. The connectivist characteristic were demonstrated in the sharing and reflecting on each other's evaluations within the wiki, even though the contact was no direct or through 'same time discussion' there was for a me a shared connection to my peers in relation to their analysis and perceptions of the material. So in summary, overall my the learning outcomes of this activity outweighed the technological issues I experienced, and I would feel confident enough to have this style of scaffolded Elearning tool in my teacher tool box.

No comments:
Post a Comment